28 March 2026 · 6 min read · By David Marrani
Constitutional law is sometimes treated as a technical specialism within public law, of interest mainly to those who study or litigate the constitutions of states. In practice it is something broader: a method for asking how authority is allocated, constrained and made accountable. That method does not stop at the boundary of the state. It is at least as useful inside universities, regulators, professional bodies and complex private institutions.
Five questions sit at the heart of constitutional thinking. Who holds authority within this institution? How is that authority limited? How is it reviewed? How can it be amended? And what happens when it is exceeded? These questions are as productive when applied to a university senate, a quality assurance body or a partnership board as they are when applied to a parliament or a court.
Universities, regulators, professional associations and large private organisations all have constitutional moments — restructurings, mergers, new charters, contested transitions of leadership — when these questions become unavoidable. Approaching such moments with the discipline of constitutional analysis tends to produce more resilient institutions and fewer regrets a decade later.
It also tends to clarify what the institution is actually for. Constitutional thinking forces an articulation of purpose, because authority cannot be allocated coherently without a view of the ends it serves. Institutions that have done this work move with more confidence; institutions that have avoided it tend to drift.
Hypothetical example (illustrative only, not client work): during a leadership transition, an institution discovers that its rules give no body the right to review interim decisions. Comparing how its instruments allocate powers to the outgoing leader, the interim office and the board shows which decisions lack any review route.
One value of the constitutional lens is that it reveals choices where habit had hidden them. The structure of a board, the relationship between academic and commercial governance, the procedure for reviewing executive decisions — none of these are natural facts. Each is a design choice with alternatives. Constitutional analysis lays the alternatives on the table and asks the institution to choose deliberately.
As institutions operate across more jurisdictions and face more contested decisions, the implicit constitutional design of an institution becomes either a strategic asset or a strategic liability. Institutions whose constitutional design is clear, consistent and capable of accommodating disagreement are well placed to navigate difficult periods. Institutions whose design is opaque or contradictory tend to discover this at the worst possible moment.
Constitutional thinking does not produce a template. It produces a discipline: a habit of asking the right questions before reaching for an answer. The output looks different for a university, a regulator and a private foundation. The method is the same.
For a sustained study of constitutional ideas in one system: David Marrani, Dynamics in the French Constitution: Decoding French Republican Ideas (Routledge, 2013).
This theme runs through much of my published work and informs the institutional governance practice. To discuss an engagement, please get in touch.